Best NHL Players Not in the Hockey Hall of Fame, Copyright 2023 NS Sports Media Pros Ltd (N.S., Canada licenced) company website. One of best players on the Bears' vaunted 46 defense, McMichael earned his first of two first-team All-Pro honors in 1985 while helping Chicago capture its only Lombardi Trophy. Twice Lacroix led the WHA in scoring, and he was named to the league's postseason All Star Team three times. While not perfect measures of performance, these advanced stats provide quality comparable numbers that permit us to tease out a goalies productivity from his teams. Mogilny was among the most injured players of his time, rarely playing more than 70 games per season. A member of the NFL's All-2010s Team, Willis twice led the NFL in tackles. And despite Manning's departure in 2012, a 34-year-old Wayne earned Pro Bowl honors that season while catching passes from a rookie quarterback named Andrew Luck. He was part of the 1993 Kings team that reached the Stanley Cup Final for the first time in franchise history and served as captain of the Kings for four seasons. He has been selected to play in six NHL All-Star Games and was named captain of one of the squads in 2009. He later won back-to-back Lady Byng Trophies for gentlemanly play in 2010 and 2011. If Lindros had stayed healthy, there is little doubt he was bound for the Hockey Hall of Fame. That's more than HOFers Terry Sawchuk (445 . Shero led the Flyers back to the Stanley Cup Final in 1976, but they fell to the Montreal Canadiens. The Hockey Hall of Fame is set to induct the class of 2022 this weekend, officially recognizing a group of six important figures for their careers and . He has also hosted several NHL awards shows and remains a well-known, loved and respected voice of the sport. 25 all time in points. CBC host Ron MacLean deserves to be in the Hockey Hall of Fame for his work as a broadcaster. The man they nicknamed "Big Walt" played 19 seasons in the NHL with the Jets, Coyotes, Blues and Thrashers. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 2017 Hockey Hall of Fame Legends Induction program Selanne Kariya Recchi at the best online prices at eBay! A five-time All-Star who finished in the top 10 of NL MVP voting three times between 2000 and 2004, Helton's status as a non-Hall of Famer is beginning to look like a . He clearly exudes a love for the game of hockey that shows in his work. Teaming with Teemu Selanne while with the Ducks, Kariya was half of one of the league's most dangerous offensive duos. Even though I grew up in New England, I went against the grain and followed another Original Six team, the Montreal Canadiens. Of the 90 players with at least 1,000 career points, Roenick ranks 27th in shooting percentage (15.64%). The 14th overall pick in the 1974 draft, Gradishar earned Pro Bowl and All-Pro honors in 1977 while leading Denver's "Orange Crush" defense, a unit that helped spearhead the Broncos' first Super Bowl appearance. He finished his NHL career with 448 goals and 988 points in 1,005 games. As listed in Table 2 below, many of Turgeons nearest Hall compatriots did not earn much in the way of hardware either. In 1,346 NHL games, the talented Czech has scored 665 goals and 1,653 points while playing for Pittsburgh, Washington, the Rangers and Flyers. He also won the Norris Trophy in 2003-04 as the NHL's top defenseman. But, in the interest of putting the best scorers in NHL history in the Hall of Fame, the PHWA could do worse than inducting at least two eligible players with at least 400 PAT in the Hall . A Pro Bowler each season from 1983-86, Jacoby's blocking helped John Riggins rush for a then Super Bowl record in Washington's win over Miami in Super Bowl XVII. Few goalies have been as good as Brodeur has for as long as Brodeur has. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'thehockeywriters_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_7',828,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-thehockeywriters_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0'); In his quest for Hall of Fame induction, it helps that Mogilny was also one of the best players of his day, although he did play in a high-scoring era. Jagr won a pair of Stanley Cups with Pittsburgh early in his career when teamed with Mario Lemieux. Hall-of-famer. Lemieux's numbers are good, but not outstanding. He had four seasons during which he put up numbers that would challenge for the Vezina today. A valued member of Minnesota's "Purple People Eaters" defensive line, Marshall holds numerous NFL records, including the most seasons played by a defensive player (20, along with Junior Seau and Darrell Green), most consecutive games by a defensive player (282), most consecutive starts by a defensive player (270), and most career fumble recoveries (30). Lemieux won four Stanley Cups during his career and is one of only 10 players in NHL history to win a title with three different teams. We and our partners share information on your use of this website to help improve your experience. 6:28 pm ET. 27th all time) in his 1,639 game NHL career. Its a little harder to judge defensemen on HHOF worthiness because of how the position has changed over time and the lack of historical tools available to measure the core responsibilities. He was a scoring legend with the Philadelphia Flyers during the 1980s, averaging 1.12 points per game during his prime from 1981-1986. The recent2021 Hockey Hall of Fame (HHOF) Class inductionannouncement caused a stir because of who was and was not included. Modano only made one NHL All-Star Team, Andreychuk and Mike Gartner made zero. "Cujo" stands No. The primary job of a defender is to limit the number of dangerous shots his goalie faces, but much of the available data doesnt go back far enough to help us differentiate between the type of shots. Burns was a three-time winner of the Jack Adams Award as Coach of the Year, winning it with three different teams: Montreal, Toronto and Boston. Therefore, the missing ranked players in each table are only active players, dissimilar positions, or from a different era. Housley is already a member of the U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame, but it still waiting for a call from the HHOF in Toronto. John Beezer Vanbiesbrouck accumulated some fairly impressive hardware during his 20-season NHL career. His ideas helped eliminate obstruction and helped open up the game after the 2004-05 lockout. The Scarborough, Ontario native was a true power forward who scored 440 goals and 952 points in 1,144 games. OK, let's be clear here. Smith's extreme competitiveness more than made up for his 5-foot-9, 195-pound frame. Assuming the lockout ends soon, he will have a chance to add to these numbers for several more years. The Czech goalie left the NHL after 2008 and spent the past few seasons in Europe. The Bengals' all-time leading passer, Anderson's boom under Bill Walsh's "West Coast" offense set the stage for Walsh's success with Joe Montana in San Francisco. He also won the Conn Smythe Trophy as the league's playoff MVP in 2002 and spent six years as captain of the Red Wings. To his credit, Tkachuk has created one of the most recognizable hockey families in the league, with two of his sons in the NHL, Matthew of the Calgary Flames and Brady of the Ottawa Senators; both are flourishing. In 2000, he helped the New Jersey Devils win the Stanley Cup. Broten finished his career with 923 points in 1,099 games. In 1,077 career NHL games, Thornton has scored 324 goals and 1,078 points. He has played more than 1,000 games (1,201), scored more than 500 goals (538) and accumulated more than 1,000 points (1,065). Paul Kariya was one of the most exciting players to watch during the 1990's. Despite his small stature, Kariya was able to make an immediate impact at the highest level with the Anaheim Ducks. In addition to his offensive ability, Brind'Amour was one of the better defensive centers in the game during his career. The native of Peterborough, Ontario, played in two NHL All-Star Games and won the Stanley Cup with the New York Rangers in 1994. The AFL's leader in touchdown catches the following season, Taylor helped the Chiefs capture their first Super Bowl win at the end of the 1969 season. The 2020 hockey Hall of Fame class was announced on Wednesday. Rick Tocchet's career numbers earn him consideration for the Hockey Hall of Fame, but some off-ice controversy that took place after his playing career may keep him out of hockey's hallowed hall. His list of accomplishments is tough to match. Whats even more telling is that Joseph never had a season of over 19 goals saved above average. Kariya, a seven-time All-Star with two Lady Byng trophies to his name, was exceptionally fast and shifty. Sundinstands out asthe highest-ever scoring Swede but was never named the best at anything, evident by his lack of trophies. Lacroix was one of the early stars for the Philadelphia Flyers, but he really became a star in 1972-73 when he signed with the Philadelphia Blazers of the WHA. He has been selected to 11 NHL All-Star Games and four postseason All-Star teams. So far, Selanne has scored 663 goals and 1,406 points in 1,341 career NHL games. He scored more points-per-game than anyone on the list and scored eleven fewer points thanDave Andreychukin four fewer seasons. Fedorov was part of the Red Wings' "Russian Five," a group of five players who played as a unit and helped make the Wings one of the league's dominant teams in the 1990s. However, he ranks 5th all-time in career left-wing points-per-game behind Hall of Famers Bobby Hull, Michel Goulet, Paul Kariya, and future HHOFer Alex Ovechkin. MacLean has served as the host of CBC's Hockey Night in Canada since 1986-87, a span of 25 years, and has been the face of that broadcast ever since. His best season came in 1974-75, when he had 106 assists and 147 points playing for the San Diego Mariners. Key fact: He was a six-time All-Star, four-time Gold Glove winner and one-time Silver Slugger. Even though I grew up in New England, I went against the grain and followed another Original Six team, the Montreal Canadiens. In 1983, his final NFL season, the 36-year-old Riley recorded eight interceptions (returning two for scores) while earning his first career All-Pro selection. Roberts played in three NHL All-Star Games and won the Masterton Trophy for dedication to hockey in 1996. Key factors included standard and advanced metrics, hardware (Stanley Cups, All-Star selections, and individual trophies), and contributions to the game. Ill be surprised if half of these players arent inducted into the Hall within the next three to five years, but theyre all certainly deserving. With more data available now versus when they retired, players like Turgeon and Fleury will have a better chance to receive the call to the Hall. Adam Oates was one of the more unselfish players in NHL history a pass-first center who led the league in assists three times and finished in the top 10 in assists 12 times. It was the third consecutive year the high-scoring winger had played in the Stanley Cup Final, playing for three different teams. Wayne Gretzky* 1979-99: 2857: 2. . Each table is ordered by total career points and only contains fellow NHLers who played during a similar era and of like positions (forwards compared to forwards, etc). He has also led the NHL in points five times and won one Hart Trophy and three Lester B. Pearson Trophies as NHL MVP. Assuming the lockout does not cancel the season, Alfredsson should be back in Ottawa once hockey resumes to add to his totals. He should be inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame shortly after he becomes eligible. He was later named to three postseason All Star Teams. Paul Coffey, right, National Hockey League Hall of Fame and four-time Stanley Cup champion (three with the Edmonton Oilers) autographs a replica Stanley Cup for Dylan Nowak of Buffalo. Teams: 49ers (1983-90); Raiders (1991); Vikings (1992-93). He finished his career with 132 goals and 313 points in 565 NHL games. As a result, he fell just short of 1,000 career games and 1,000 career points. Atlanta's first draft pick, Nobis played on just two winning teams during his 11-year tenure with the Falcons. He was the Steelers' No. Flash Hollett is an overlooked star of the early NHL who belongs in the Hockey Hall of Fame. Women and foreign players from the cold war era occupy some spots, as do NHL goaltenders and defensemen. TORONTO -- The six members of the Hockey Hall of Fame Class of 2022 were inducted Monday. In 2010, a subcategory was established for female players. In addition to winning a pair of Stanley Cups with Detroit, the native of Sverdlovsk, Russia has won four Lady Byng Trophies for gentlemanly play and three Selke Awards as the NHL's best defensive forward. He pled guilty to being involved in an effort to promote gambling in hockey in New Jersey and was sentenced to two years probation. He is best known as a member of the Kings' "Triple Crown Line" along with Charlie Simmer and Marcel Dionne. He was a leader and a real physical presence on the ice. I know all the reasons why detractors have rationalizedTurgeonsabsence from the HHOF: no Cups, no major trophies, didnt stand out during his era,and other qualitativeconclusions that dont hold up under scrutiny. Originally, there were two categories for induction, players and builders, and in 1961, a third category for on-ice officials was introduced. He made the Cup Final in 1996 but he and the Florida Panthers were swept by the Colorado Avalanche. The Dolphins have a slew of Canton-worthy players who still haven't gotten the call. Pavel Datsyuk is one of the best all-around forwards in the game today and has already won enough hardware over the course of his NHL career to garner serious Hall of Fame consideration. Lowe was a defensive defenseman and steady force on the Oilers dynasty teams of the 1980s, best known for their offensive explosiveness. The smooth native of Toronto scored 40 or more goals in five straight seasons including a career-high 51 in 1981-82. He was a great agitator and a player who played his best when game counted most. Hayes is a member of the NFL's All-1980s Team. Scott Niedermayer will be eligible for the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2013 and shouldn't have to wait too long for the call from the hall. He was one of the best stay-at-home defensemen in the history of the NHL, ranked 11th all-time in career defensive point shares. A four-time Pro Bowler, Anderson led the NFL in completion percentage three times. Tocchet also accumulated 2,972 penalty minutes in his career with the Flyers, Penguins, Kings, Bruins, Capitals and Coyotes. He reached the Stanley Cup final twice as a coach, coming up short in 1989 with Montreal before winning it all with the New Jersey Devils in 2003. Hes not as elite defensively as Scott Stevens or Chris Chelios, but he scored more per game than they did. Over his 20-season career, he scored 1,216 points in 1,363 games for five different teams. November 14, 2022. In 2007, he became the first European-born player to captain a team to the Stanley Cup Final. The two are closer in their goalie point shares numbers, with Joseph (167.17, ranked 9th all-time) edging out Vanbiesbrouck (152.75, 12th). He was the prototypical NHL power forward for ten seasons with the Winnipeg Jets/Phoenix Coyotes organization. Dominik Hasek earned his nickname "The Dominator" for his strong play on the ice. While he has yet to receive the call to Canton,Matthews was inducted into the Browns' Ring of Honorin 2019. A member of theBroncos' Ring of Fame, Gradishar is credited with over 2,000 tackles during his 10-year career. He won three Stanley Cups with Detroit before finishing his career with the Ducks, Blue Jackets and Capitals. DPS of players in McCrimmons EraPlayer NameSeasonsDPSRankRay Bourque*1979-01118.891Scott Stevens*1982-04115.642Larry Robinson*1972-92108.984Chris Chelios*1983-10108.695Larry Murphy*1980-0191.298Al MacInnis*1981-0490.739Brad McCrimmon1979-9782.9211. All Time. Enter your search keyword. He made it look easy, but Lidstrom played the game better than nearly anybody else in the league during the course of his career. Datsyuk has also been selected to play in four NHL All-Star Games, been named to one postseason All-Star Team and had the NHL's best plus/minus rating in 2007-08. No European-born player has more points than Jagr. The Hockey Hall of Fame. Alexander Mogilny was an offensive force during his NHL career, scoring 473 goals and 1,032 points in 990 games with the Sabres, Canucks, Devils and Maple Leafs. Obviously not all inductees are former NHLers. After the lockout, Shanahan helped make changes to the game to help get the game out of the "dead puck era." He finished his NHL career with 264 goals and 1,142 points in 1,564 career NHL games. For whatever the reason, there are numerous deserving players who are still hoping to earn a spot in football immortality. Down Goes Brown: They're not Hall of Famers, but let's honor a Hall of Very Good. . There was no Hall of Fame class in 2021, so this list includes players who played their final game in both 2018 and 2019. The super pest scored 379 goals and 786 points in 1,215 career NHL games. However, both standard and advanced metrics show that he belongs in the HHOF. Induction into the Hockey Hall of Fame is the highest individual honor a hockey player, coach or GM can achieve over the course of his career. One could argue Gretzky actually belongs in the Hall of Fame in two categories - as a player and as a builder. in Quarterbacks. Also, after factoring in the era in which he played, his adjusted points are 9th all-time (896). Lowe scored the first-ever goal for the Oilers in their NHL history. That total is not only a Falcons' franchise record, it is unofficially the the most tackles ever credited to a player in NFL history,according to the Falcons' team website. Rick "Nifty" Middleton was a high-scoring winger for the Rangers and Bruins in the 1970s and 80s. With Saturday's induction, there are now 362 former players, coaches and . The Hamilton, Ontario, native played in a pair of NHL All-Star Games and finally won the Stanley Cup in 2004 with the Tampa Bay Lightning. As forJeremy Roenick, hes behind Turgeon in the offensive categories above and doesnthave thecareerhardwareto boot. Tasker's brilliance was on display during the opening minutes of Super Bowl XXVII. > Notable players: Bobby Orr, Ray Bourque. 5 all-time with 1,651 games played. He finished the . The 39-year-old Swede has spent his entire NHL career in Ottawa and has scored 416 goals and 1,082 points in 1,131 games. Hasek played in 16 NHL seasons and won 389 career games, good for No. I thought it would be interesting to dive into who are the best eligible players by position not in the Hall. 10 10. He is the third-ever American-born NHL player to reach the 500-goal mark and finished with 513 goals and 1,206 points in 1,363 games. The Hurricanes retired Brind'Amour's jersey in 2011, and he currently works as an assistant coach for the Carolina organization. Scouting Reports Johnson led the NFL in receptions and receiving yards on multiple occasions. All-Rookie Team, All-Star Game (x6), Maurice "Rocket" Richard Trophy, World Juniors Silver, World Championships Silver (x2), World Championships Gold, Olympic Gold (x2) Since he was an officer in the Soviet Army at the time, the USSR government charged him with desertion. "Freddy the Fog" was also one of the first NHL coaches to study Russian and European training methods, and adapted some of them to the NHL game. Bob Frid-USA TODAY Sports. In addition to Winnipeg/Phoenix, Numminen played for the Dallas Stars and Buffalo Sabres. Thornton has topped the 100-point mark three times and has also been named to three postseason All-Star Teams. Its for these reasons that I think Vanbiesbrouck deserves a Hall induction before Joseph. In 1,006 career NHL games, Larmer scored 441 goals and 1,012 points. In 234 playoff games, he scored 80 goals (No. Oh boy. Offensive Players. Turgeon has the most points of any eligible player not in the Hall of Fame with 1,327 (515 goals, 812 assists) in 1,294 games. Angels: Bobby Grich#, 2B. 5 all time in games played. Concussions forced him to sit out the 2000-01 season, and he was just a shadow of himself after that, toiling in virtual obscurity for the Rangers, Stars and Leafs before hanging up his skates for good after the 2006-07 season. Each table is ordered by total career points and only contains fellow NHLers who played during a similar era and of like positions (forwards compared to forwards, etc). He won a Stanley Cup with Pittsburgh in 1991-92, scoring 19 points in 14 playoff games. Jarome Iginla did not deserve his Hockey Hall of Fame induction. Turgeon played in four NHL All-Star Games and won the Lady Byng Trophy for gentlemanly play in 1992-93. Matthews retired with 69.5 career sacks, 27 forced fumbles and 14 fumble recoveries. 14 all time) and 1,338 points (tied for No. With the exception of Fedorov, no player in this range won a Cup, made an All-Star Team, and won an individual performance trophy. Iginla has won a pair of Rocket Richard Trophies as the league's top goal scorer and the Art Ross Trophy as the league's leading scorer. He was the league MVP in the lockout-shortened 1994-95 season and was a first-team postseason All-Star once and a second-team All-Star once. Remember, there was no 2021 . 100 Active Potential Football Hall of Famers. Founded in 2009, The Hockey Writers is a premier destination for news and information on everything hockey. Nov 11, 2022. The Roseau, Minnesota native joined his hometown North Stars after the Olympics and became the first American to score 100 points in an NHL season. Hayes won Defensive Player of the Year in 1980 while leading the NFL with 13 interceptions. Skill-wise, his former teams and teammates have heaped praise on the explosive winger. Teams: Oilers (1985-86); Bills (1986-97) One of the greatest special teams players in NFL history, Tasker earned seven Pro Bowl nods from 1987-95. Boston Bruins. He also played in five NHL All-Star Games and was named to one postseason All-Star Team. Shop by category. With the exception of Gary Suter and Doug Wilson, everyone ranked above Gonchar in career points is already in the HHOF. Perhaps his reputation as being an offensive player but not a great all-around player early in his career has delayed his induction. A six-time Pro Bowler from 2006-10 and in 2012, Wayne led the NFL in receiving yards in 2007. This allowed me to give attention to a few less-heralded players too. He was a bad leader, an overrated scorer, and a goon. 8 with a 2.13 career GAA. Grich played 10 of his 17 seasons in the Majors with the Angels, and he is almost universally viewed as one of the most deserving of enshrinement among players not in the Hall of Fame. Still, once he's eligible, there's little doubt Recchi will eventually be inducted. In 1981, Anderson won both league MVP and Comeback Player of the Year while leading the Bengals to their first Super Bowl. The 2021 Hockey Hall of Fame (HHOF) Class induction announcement caused a stir because of who was and was not included. There were two first-year men in this year's squad in Jarome Iginla and Marian Hossa. In 2004, Bourque was inducted to the Hockey Hall of Fame. THE IDENTICAL TWINS TIER. Chelios will be eligible for the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2013. An incredibly consistent player throughout his career, Riley picked off at least four passes nine different times, tallying a career-high nine interceptions in 1976. Don Cherry belongs in the Hockey Hall of Fame.as a broadcaster. His play helped the Dolphins make the playoffs each year from 1997-01. A quick look at Claude Lemieux's career statistics and you wonder why he's a part of this conversation. He won back-to-back Selke Trophies as the NHL's best defensive forward in 2006 and 2007. He played for the Flames, Hurricanes, Maple Leafs, Panthers, Penguins and Lightning. He also led the NFL in tackles on four different occasions. Turgeon was the Habs captain and leading scorer, so it was easy to enjoy watching him play. Unlike most induction classes, there was not a single member of this year's class that got in on the first ballot. Eric Staal, Center (Quad 1) Induction Weekend festivities will run from Friday, November 11 through Sunday, November 13 . He played the same position in the same era as Mats Sundin and scored just 22 fewer points in 50 fewer games. If Propps later seasons were not beset by injuries, theres little doubt that he would have racked up enough scoring to be inducted. Hossa has played in five NHL All-Star Games and ended a strange streak when he finally won the Stanley Cup with the Blackhawks in 2010. Free shipping. Burns . NHL Leaders. Among those players are former offensive lineman Bob Kuechenberg, receivers Mark Duper andMark Claytonand running back Ricky Williams. He played the same position in the same era as Mats Sundin and scored just 22 fewer points in 50 fewer games. The Detroit native played for the Rangers, Oilers, Blues, Hurricanes, Ducks and Islanders during his NHL career, serving as captain of both the Oilers and Islanders over the course of his career. But look at Lemieux's intangibles and you understand why many people feel he belongs. He is still awaiting a call from the Hockey Hall of Fame. Hasek won a pair of Stanley Cups and helped the Senators and Sabres reach the Stanley Cup Final. Vachon broke in with the Montreal Canadiens and played on two Stanley Cup championship teams. In 1,188 career games, Iginla has scored 516 goals and 1,073 points. The American-born Housley was one of the best offensive defensemen of his era, scoring 338 goals and 1,232 points in 1,495 career NHL games with the Sabres, Jets, Blues, Flames, Devils, Capitals, Blackhawks and Maple Leafs. Teams:Patriots(1980);Bears(1981-93);Packers(1994). Shero finished his NHL coaching career with a 390-225-119 record. On Saturday, the Pro Football Hall of Fame inducted eight more members into pro football's most exclusive club. Twice, Broten was named to the NHL All-Star Game and he went on to score the game-winning goal in the Cup-clinching game for the New Jersey Devils in 1995. One of the greatest special teams players in NFL history, Tasker earned seven Pro Bowl nods from 1987-95. The World Hockey Association (French: Association mondiale de hockey) was a professional ice hockey major league that operated in North America from 1972 to 1979.It was the first major league to compete with the National Hockey League (NHL) since the collapse of the Western Hockey League in 1926. Twitter Facebook Youtube. Nowak said he made the cup mostly out of cake pans and it has enough space on it to record the championship teams and players' names for the next 38 years. Andreychuk scored 640 goals (No. He served as captain of the Oilers during the 1991-92 season and later served as coach and GM of the Oilers after his playing career was over. Related: 3 Greatest Canucks Forwards of All-Time. 21 jersey in 2006. I took great pride and pleasure and a lot of appreciation in talking to Brad about parts of the game that he saw in a way that I certainly didnt and many others didnt. Home; NFL. At the time of his retirement, Hollett was the all-time scoring leader among defensemen. In his second season, Taylor led the AFL in average yards per catch while helping lead the Chiefs to the first-ever Super Bowl.